Opinion: Fixing the disconnect between archaeologists and Indigenous individuals

Article content material

A current article entitled “Folks arrived in Fort McMurray Wooden Buffalo space not less than 11,000 years in the past” solutions the massive query that archaeologists have been asking for a few years—when did individuals come to the world? The one drawback with this query (as Woywitka et al. are distinctive archaeologists) is that they’re answering a query that Indigenous individuals within the space have already got a solution for.

Commercial 2

Article content material

The information that Indigenous peoples had been residing within the Fort McMurray space maybe so long as 13,000 years in the past was one thing they’d probably realized after they had been younger via tales advised to them by their grandparents.

Article content material

Right this moment these tales proceed to be encoded into their land and language with panorama options attributed to the actions of Pleistocene megafauna who died out round 11,000 years in the past.   

So why are archeologists right this moment doing analysis on questions that have already got solutions? That is largely resulting from archaeology’s colonial roots.

For instance, early British archaeologists in Egypt and elsewhere tended to easily use locals as handbook labour earlier than bringing the spoils of their expeditions again to Britain. In North America, archaeology was outright racist throughout its infancy typically attributing main archeological websites to ‘others’ relatively than the present Indigenous inhabitants that Canadian and American governments had been busy attempting to colonize.

Commercial 3

Article content material

Fortunately a lot has modified in archaeology because of the introduction of Indigenous archaeology, the place archaeology is motivated by the objectives and aspirations of Indigenous peoples typically with them on the helm.  

So why has this disconnect between archaeologists and Indigenous individuals endured within the Treaty 8 area of Alberta—particularity within the Fort McMurray space the place forestry and oilsands growth has required in depth archaeological investigations over the past a number of many years?

The newest response from Albertan regulators is that to incorporate Indigenous peoples within the regulatory course of related to historic (archaeological) assets would run counter to the present authorities’s Pink Tape Discount Coverage. This lies in distinction to the comparable treaty context of Treaty 8 B.C., the place Indigenous peoples are consulted on archaeological permits.  

Commercial 4

Article content material

Regardless of the grim regulatory scene in Alberta, some tutorial archaeologists—not certain by provincial rules and proponents’ budgets—are making developments in constructing relationships with Treaty 8 First Nations in Alberta. A lot of this progress is acts of service beneath the tragic context of the seek for unmarked graves related to Indian Residential Colleges.  

How can we get Indigenous archaeology to start out occurring within the Fort McMurray space within the context of assessments linked to forestry and oilsands growth?

One method is for Indigenous communities to companion with consulting archaeologists in significant methods. Significant doesn’t imply an organization makes use of the neighborhood’s title to get contracts in change for 5 per cent of the revenue.

Quite these relationships ought to embrace technical coaching alternatives for youth; creating moral areas for Indigenous Information to be shared and guarded; and a transfer away from giving higher privilege to ‘skilled’ publications and conferences in the direction of the creation of neighborhood merchandise and shows.

Solely then can archaeologists catch as much as the Indigenous understanding of the previous and begin collaboratively asking questions sooner or later.  

Ave Dersch, Ph.D. is an archaeologist who works with a number of First Nations within the Fort McMurray area.

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback could take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve got enabled e-mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e-mail in the event you obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you comply with or if a consumer you comply with feedback. Go to our Group Tips for extra info and particulars on learn how to modify your e-mail settings.

Be part of the Dialog

Commercial 1